Employee involvement and participation in SMEs: a synthesis of extant research
Keywords:Human Resource Management, Small and Medium Sized Firms, Systematic Literature Review
It is widely acknowledged that small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) cannot afford underutilize their workforce and owner/managers encourage ways to involve employees. In this article, we focus on what is known about formal employee involvement and participation (EIP) practice in SMEs. Based on a systematic, “aggregative” literature review (Briner and Denyer 2012; Gough et al. 2012) we identify key research on EIP in SMEs that is embedded in practice and provides utility for practitioners and policy makers. The findings not only allow us to comment briefly on the evolution of EIP research in SMEs, but to identify methodically what is known and not known about EIP practice in SMEs. We go therefore beyond the limited review provide by Sameer and Őzbilgin (2014) and identify with a higher level of confidence three key directions for future academic research.
Allen, Mathew R., Jeff Ericksen, and Christopher J. Collins. (2013). “Human Resource Management, employee exchange relationships, and performance in small businesses.” Human Resource Management 52 (2): 153-174.
Andries, Petra, and Dirk Czarnitzki. (2014). “Small firm innovation performance and employee involvement.” Small Business Economics 43 (1): 21-38.
Antcliff, Valerie, and Richard Saundry. 2009. “Accompaniment, workplace representation and disciplinary outcomes in British workplaces – just a formality?” British Journal of Industrial Relations 47 (1): 100-21.
Barrett, Rowena, and Susan Mayson. 2007. “Human resource management in growing small firms.” Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development 14 (2): 307-20.
Barrett, Rowena, and Al Rainnie. 2002. “What’s so special about small firms. Developing an integrated approach to analysing small firm industrial relations.” Work Employment and Society 16 (3): 415-531.
Bayo-Moriones, Alberto, and Martin Lazarra-Kintana. 2009. “Profit-sharing plans and affective commitment: does the context matter?” Human Resource Management 48 (2): 207-226..
Blasi, Joseph, Douglas Kruse, James Sesil and Maya Kroumova. 2003. “An assessment of employee ownership in the United States with implications for the EU.” International Journal of Human Resource Management 14 (6): 893-919.
Brewster, Chris. 1999. “Strategic human resource management: the value of different paradigms.” Management International Review 39 (3): 45-64.
Brewster, Chris. 2007. “Comparative HRM: European views and perspectives.” International Journal of Human Resource Management 18 (5): 769-87.
Brewster, Chris, Richard Croucher, Geoff Wood, and Michael Brookes. 2007. “Collective and individual voice: convergence in Europe?" International Journal of Human Resource Management 18 (7): 1246-62.
Briner, Rob and David Denyer. 2012. “Systematic review and evidence synthesis as a practice and scholarship tool.” In Oxford handbook of evidence-based management, edited by Denise M. Rousseau, 112-29. Oxford: OUP.
Bryson, Alex, Rafael Gomez, Tobias Kretschmer, and Paul Willman. 2007. “The diffusion of workplace voice and high-commitment human resource management practices in Britain, 1984-1998.” Industrial and Corporate Change 16 (3): 394-426.
CABS. 2015. “Academic Journal Guide.” The Chartered Association of Business Schools. Accessed July 5, 2016. https://charteredabs.org/academic-journal-guide-2015/ ,
Cassell Catherine, Sara Nadin, Melanie Gray, and Chris Clegg. 2002. “Exploring human resource management practices in small and medium sized enterprises.” Personnel Review 31 (5/6): 671-692.
Castrogiovanni, Gary J. 2011. “The role of human capital factors in small business performance and success.” In Human Resource Management in Small Business, edited by Cary L. Cooper and Ronald J. Burke, 71-92. Cheltenham: Edgar Elgar.
Cox, Annette, Mick Marchington, and Jane Suter. 2009. “Employee involvement and participation: developing the concept of institutional embeddedness using WERS 2004”. International Journal of Hunan Resource Management 20 (10): 2150-2169.
Della Torre, Edoardo, and Luca Solari. 2013. “High-performance work systems and the change management process in medium-sized firms.” The International Journal of Human Resource Management 24 (13): 2583-2607.
Diez, Graham, Ton van der Wiele, Jos van Iwaarden and Julie Brosseau. 2006. “HRM inside UK-e-commerce firms: innovations in the ‘new’ economy and continuities with the ‘old’. International Small Business Journal 24 (5): 443-470.
Dundon, Tony, Andrew Wilkinson, Mick Marchington, and Paul Ackers. 2004. “The meanings and purpose of employee voice.” International Journal of Human Resource Management 15 (6): 1149-70.
Eurofound. 2015. “Third European Company Survey – Overview, report: workplace practices – patterns, performance and well-being.” Luxembourg: Publication of the European Union.
Frick, Kaj, and David Walters.1998. “Worker representation on health and safety in small enterprises: lessons from a Swedish approach.” International Labour Review 137 (3): 367-389.
Fulton, Lionel. 2013. “Workplace representation in Europe.” Labour Research Department and ETUI. Accessed June 13, 2016. http://www.worker-participation.eu/National-Industrial-Relations/Across-Europe/Workplace-Representation2.
Gilman, Mark, and Simon Raby. 2013. “National contexts as a predictor of high-performance work system effectiveness in small-to-medium-size enterprises (SMEs): a UK-French comparative analysis.” The International Journal of Human Resource Management 24 (3): 372-390.
Gilman, Mark, Simon Raby, and Amanda Pyman. 2015. “The contours of employee voice in SMEs: the importance of context.” Human Resource Management Journal 25 (4): 563-79.
Gough, David, James Thomas, and Sandy Oliver. 2012. “Clarifying differences between review designs and methods.” Systematic Reviews 1 (28): 1-9.
Guest, David. 1998. “Is the psychological contract worth taking seriously?” Journal of Organizational Behaviour 19 (S1): 649-64.
Hallberg, Ulrika, and Wilmar B. Schaufeli. 2006. “”The same” but different?” European Psychologist 11 (2): 119-27.
Harley, Bill, Jeff Hyman, and Paul Thompson, eds. 2005. Participation and Democracy at Work: essays in Honour of Harvie Ramsay. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Harney, Brian, and Dundon, Tony. 2006. “Capturing complexity: developing an integrated approach to analyzing HRM in SMEs.” Human Resource Management 16 (1): 48-73.
Haynes, Peter, Peter Boxall, and Keith Macky. 2006. “Union reach, the ‘representation gap’ and the prospects for unionism in New Zealand.” Journal of Industrial Relations 48 (2): 193-216.
Hayton, James C. 2004. “Strategic human capital management in SME´s: an empirical study of entrepreneurial performance.” Human Resource Management 42 (4): 375-91.
Helfen, Markus, and Elke S. Schuessler. 2009. “Uncovering divergence: management attitudes towards HRM practices and works council presence in German SMEs.” Economic and Industrial Democracy 30 (2): 207-240.
Katz, Jerome A., Howard E. Aldrich, Theresa M. Welbourne, and Paul M. Williams.. 2000. “Guest Editor's Comments Special Issue on Human Resource Management and the SME: Toward a New Synthesis.” Entrepreneurship: Theory and Practice 25 (1): 7-26.
Katzenbach, Jon R. 2000. Peak performance: aligning the hearts and minds of your employees. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
Macpherson, Allan, and Robin Holt. 2007. “Knowledge, learning and small firm growth: a systematic review of the evidence.” Research Policy 36 (2): 172-92.
Marchington, Mick. 2015. “Analysing the forces shaping employee involvement and participation (EIP) at organization level in liberal market economics (LMEs).” Human Resource Management Journal 25 (1): 1-18.
Marchington, Mick. 2007. “Foreword.” Human Resource Management Journal 18 (1-2): 1-2.
Marchington, Mick, and Adrian Wilkinson. 2005. “Direct participation and involvement.” In Personnel Management in Britain (4th edition), edited by Stephen Bach, 398-423. Oxford: Blackwell.
Marchington, Mick, and Jane Suter. 2013. “Where informality really matters: patterns of employee involvement and participation (EIP) in a non-union firm.” Industrial Relations 52 (S1): 284-313.
Moore, Sian, and Ian Read. 2006. “Collective organization in small- and medium-sized enterprises – an application of mobilization theory.” Human Resource Management Journal 16 (4): 357-375.
Nolan, Ciara. T., and Thomas N. Garavan. 2015. “Human Resource Development in SMEs: A systematic review of the literature.” International Journal of Management Review 18 (1): 85-107.
Őzbilgin, Muhammed. 2004. “International” human resource management. Academic parochialism in editorial boards of the top 22 journals on international human resource management.” Personnel Review 33 (2): 205-21.
Peccei, Riccardo, Helen Bewley, Howard Gospel, and Paul Willman. 2010. “Antecedents and outcomes of information disclosure to employees in the UK 1990-2004: the role of employee voice.” Human Relations 63 (3): 419-38.
Pyman, Amanda, Brian Cooper, Julian Teicher, and Peter Holland. 2006. “A comparison of the effectiveness of employee voice arrangements in Australia.” Industrial Relations Journal 37 (5): 543-59.
Pyman, Amanda, Peter Holland, Julian Teicher, and Brian Cooper. 2010. “Industrial relations climate, employee voice and managerial attitudes to unions: an Australian study.” British Journal of Industrial Relations 48 (1): 460-80.
Richardson, Mike, Andy Danford, Paul Steward, and Valeria Pulignano. (2010). “Employee participation and involvement: experiences of aerospace and automobile workers in the UK and Italy.” European Journal of Industrial Relations 16 (1): 21-37.
Sameer, Muhammad, and Mustafa F. Őzbilgin. 2014. “Employee voice in the SME context.” In Handbook of research on employee voice, edited by Adrian Wilkinson, Jimmy Donaghey, Tony Dundon, and Richard B. Freeman, 410-20. Northampton: Edward Elgar.
Schwartz, Tony. 2010. The way we are working, isn’t working. New York: Free Press.
Strauss, George. 2006. “Worker participation – some under-considered issues.” Industrial Relations 45 (4): 778-803.
Townsend, Keith, Adrian Wilkinson, and John Burgess. 2012. “Filling the gaps: patters of formal and informal participation.” Economic and Industrial Democracy 34 (2): 337-354.
Tranfield, David, David Denyer, and Palminder Smart. 2003. “Towards a methodology for developing evidence-informed management knowledge by means of systematic review.” British Journal of Management 14 (2): 207-22.
Truss, Catherine. 2002. “Shifting the paradigm in human resource management: from the resource base view to complex adaptive systems.” Research Papers in Human Resource Management, Kingston Business School, Accessed July 29, 2016.
Uhlaner, Lorraine, Andre van Stel, Valerie Duplat, and Haibo Zhou. (2013). „Disentangling the effects of organizational capabilities, innovation and firm size on SME sales growth.” Small Business Economics 41 (3): 581–607.
Ulrich, Dave, and Wendy Ulrich. 2010. The why of work. New York: McGraw Hill.
Walters, David. 1998a. “Employee representation on health and safety in small enterprises.” Employee Relations 20 (2): 164-179.
Walters, David. 1998b. “Employee representation and health and safety.” Employee Relations 20 (2): 180-195.
Walters, David. 2004. “Worker representation and health and safety in small enterprises in Europe.” Industrial Relations Journal 25(2): 169-186.
Whitfield, Keith, and George Strauss. 2000. “Methods matter: changes in industrial relations research and their implications.” British Journal of Industrial Relations 38 (1): 141-51.
Wilkinson, Adrian, Tony Dundon, and Irina Grugulis. 2007. “Information but not consultation: exploring employee involvement in SMEs.” International Journal of Human Resource Management 18 (7): 1279-1297.
Wilkinson, Adrian, Tony Dundon, and Mick Marchington. 2013. “Employee involvement and voice.” In Managing Human Resources, edited by Stephen Bach, and Martin Edwards, 268–88. Oxford: Blackwell.
Wilkinson, Adrian, Tony Dundon, Jimmy Donaghey, and Richard B. Freeman. 2014. “Employee voice: charting new terrain.” In Handbook of research on employee voice, edited by Adrian Wilkinson, Jimmy Donaghey, Tony Dundon, and Richard B. Freeman, 3-16. Northampton: Edward Elgar.
Wilkinson, Adrian, Paul J. Gollan, Mick Marchington, and David Lewin. 2010. “Conceptualizing employee participation in organizations.” In Oxford handbook of participation in organizations, edited by Paul J. Gollan, David Lewin, Mick Marchington, and Adrian Wilkinson. Oxford: OUP.
Wilkinson, Adrian, Mick Marchington, and Paul Ackers. 2004. “Changing patterns of employee voice.” Journal of Industrial Relations 46 (3): 298-322.
Wood, Steven, and Mark P. Fenton O´Creevy. 2005. “Direct involvement, representation and employee voice in UK multinationals in Europe.” European Journal of Industrial Relations 11 (1): 27-50.