Virginia Woolf's Bridges: Point of View and Epistemology of the Outsiders in Three Guineas

Authors

  • Aránzazu Hernández Piñero Universidad de Zaragoza

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1344/Lectora2021.27.12

Keywords:

point of view, epistemology, difference, feminism, value

Abstract

In this paper, I analyze the figure of the bridge and its key role in the development of Woolf's arguments in Three guineas. I will argue that the bridge symbolizes the notion of point of view elaborated by the author: a situated and differentiated perspective constructed from the experiences of women. I will argue that a different experience results into the construction of a non-hegemonic, different point of view that provides an "other" knowledge, the knowledge of outsiders. As a consequence, the unsolvable dilemmas as seen from the dominant perspective can be resolved if they are approached from the perspective of outsiders, which has epistemological and axiological implications. I will also argue that these ideas are to be found decades later in contemporary feminism, both as acknowledged legacies and through unexplored affinities. Finally, I will showcase thematic and methodological affinities between Woolf's approach, Anglo-Saxon feminist epistemologies and those of radical women of color in the United States.

References

Adán, Carme (2006), Feminismo y conocimiento, A Coruña, Spiral Maior.

Anzaldúa, Gloria (1987), Borderlands/La frontera: The New Mestiza, San Francisco, Aunt Lute.

Anzaldúa, Gloria y Cherríe Moraga (1981), This Bridge Called My Back: Writings by Radical Women of Color, Watertown, Persephone Press.

Banfield, Ann (2000), The Phantom Table: Woolf, Fry, Russell and The Epistemology of Modernism, Cambridge, Cambridge UP.

Bea, Emilia y Encarnación Fernández Ruiz-Gálvez (coords.) (2017), Cien años de discurso femenino sobre la guerra y la paz, Valencia, Tirant lo Blanch.

Black, Naomi (2004), Virginia Woolf as Feminist, Nueva York, Cornell UP.

Fricker, Miranda (2001), "El feminismo en la epistemología: Pluralismo sin postmodernismo", Feminismo y filosofía. Un compendio, Miranda Fricker y Jennifer Hornsby (dirs.), Barcelona, Idea Books: 161-180.

Grau, Elena (2006), "Virginia Woolf: la mirada de la estranya", Col·lecció Pensament per la Pau, 3: 41-63.

Hernández Piñero, Aránzazu (2014), "(Des)conexiones (trans)atlánticas: recepciones estadounidenses del feminismo italiano de la diferencia sexual", Daimon, 63: 81-95. <https://doi.org/10.6018/daimon/199721>

Hill Collins, Patricia (1986), "Learning from the Outsider Within: The Sociological Significance of Black Feminist Thought", Social Problems, 33 (6): 14-32.

Irigaray, Luce (1985), El cuerpo a cuerpo con la madre. El otro género de la naturaleza. Otro modo de sentir, Barcelona, LaSal.

Maldonado Acevedo, Ana (2009), Virginia Woolf y el ensayo modernista sobre Londres. The London Scene, Huelva, Universidad de Huelva.

Marcus, Jane (2006), "Introduction", Three Guineas, Virginia Woolf, Nueva York, Harvest Book: xxxv-lxxii.

Muraro, Luisa (2001), "Guerras que he visto", Guerras que yo he visto. Saberes de mujeres en la guerra, Luisa Muraro et al., Madrid, Horas y HORAS: 39-46.

—(2005), "Feminismo y política de las mujeres", Duoda, 28: 39-47.

—(2010), "La verdad de las mujeres", Duoda, 38: 71-126.

Rampello, Liliana (2009), Virginia Woolf. La vida en la escritura, Madrid, Narcea.

Rich, Adrienne (2010), Sobre mentiras, secretos y silencios, Madrid, Horas y HORAS. [1983]

Ruíz Callejón, Encarna (2014), "Virginia Woolf: la política de los afectos de las 'hijas de los hombres con educación'", Daimon, 63: 27-44. <https://doi.org/10.6018/daimon/199261>

Torras, Meri (2004), "Feminismo e coñecemento. Da experiencia das mulleres ao cíborg. Carme Adán. A Coruña, Espiral Maior, 2003", Lectora: revista de dones i textualitat, 10: 425-427.

Woolf, Virginia (1994), La señora Dalloway, Madrid, Cátedra. [1925]

—(1999), Tres guineas, Barcelona, Lumen. [1938]

—(2003), Un cuarto propio, Madrid, horas y HORAS. [1929]

—(2010), "Pensamientos de paz durante un ataque aéreo", La muerte de la polilla y otros escritos, Madrid, Capitán Swing: 29-35. [1942]

—(2016), Al faro, Madrid, Cátedra. [1927]

Young, Iris (2000), La justicia y la política de la diferencia, Madrid, Cátedra. [1990]

Published

2021-10-27

How to Cite

[1]
Hernández Piñero, A. 2021. Virginia Woolf’s Bridges: Point of View and Epistemology of the Outsiders in Three Guineas. Lectora: Journal of Women and Textuality. 27 (Oct. 2021), 243–257. DOI:https://doi.org/10.1344/Lectora2021.27.12.