Obstetric violence: An approach to the concept and a discussion regarding the terminology
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1344/musas2019.vol4.num2.2Keywords:
obstetric violence, abuse, disrespect, maternity, birth, bioethicsAbstract
Introduction
There is concern related to the mistreatment, lack of respect or violence that health institutions exert on women in childbirth care. There is no unanimity on the proper terminology to name it. This work aims to explore the meaning of the different terms used to define this situation.
Methodology
Review of the scientific literature. The keywords were: «disrespect», «abuse»; «dehumanized care or obstetric violence», «childbirth» and «birth»; and in Spanish: «abuso», «maltrato», «violencia obstrétrica», «violencia institucional», and «parto humanizado» or «parto respetado».
Results and Discussion
Bohren et al state that «mistreatment» is a more inclusive term than «obstetric violence», «dehumanized care» and «disrespect and abuse», since it encompasses the experiences of women and health professionals. However, Jewkes and Penn-Kekana claim that the definitions of these concepts may be too broad to be operational. Lukasse et al. use the term «abuse» and understand that the concept encompasses «negligence, verbal, physical and sexual abuse». Sadler establishes a clear link between obstetric violence and gender violence and looks for its origins in the birth of obstetrics as a discipline.
Conclusions
The concept of «obstetric violence» is closely related to politics and power relations that seek obedience and submission of the female body while it also reveals that the experience of motherhood is part of the domain of biopolitics. For health professionals to accept the term, it is important to recognize that health practices are developed in a social environment in which a historical framework has been built with a set of internal beliefs, rules and practices that reproduce gender ideologies in health workers.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Authors publishing in this journal agree with the following terms:
- Authors hold the copyright, but MUSAS holds the right of first publication.
- Manuscripts will be disseminated with the Creative Commons CC BY-NC license, which allows sharing it with third parties as long as they recognize the authorship, the first publication right held by MUSAS and the license’s conditions